Salty Pimp Ice Cream Sundae & Awesomesauce

July 16, 2015 , In: Sweet Stuff , With: No Comments

Salty Pimp Sundae & Awesomesauce |

Disasters sometimes happen.

Ice cream is awesome.  Home made ice cream is awesome.  Home made chocolate sauce, aka Awesomesauce from Big Gay Ice Cream with home made ice cream is even more awesome.

Making Awesomesauce and forgetting a key ingredient, then throwing in the key ingredient and freezing melted sugar… not so awesome.


Salty Pimp Sundae & Awesomesauce |

So, as you may know, in order to tackle larger cooking tasks I like to split them up over two days.  If I’m making jam, I’ll cut the fruit and add the sugar and let it macerate overnight.  If I’m making a grain salad, I’ll cook the grain the day before.  I was super pumped about making this chocolate sauce, aka Awesomesauce, and carefully measured out the sugar and butter in a pot.  Then I put the rest of the ingredients in a bowl.  Just don’t forget to add the milk Michelle, I thought to myself as I went to bed.

The next day I started the sauce, melting the sugar and butter.  The recipe says to whisk it and make sure there is no grittiness.  I was like, WTF, how do you whisk straight up sugar?  But I stirred and stirred and stirred and finally decided to throw in the chocolate and spice component and see what happened.  I looked at it and thought ‘it’s almost like I’m missing the milk.’


Anyone who has worked with melting sugar knows what happens when you pour cold milk into hot sugar… the entire thing seizes into hard rocks.  But, I figured it was my only chance and eventually it would all melt.  In the background I could hear my youngest 8 month old climbing and getting into trouble, my husband asking, ‘Michelle, why the hell are you making chocolate sauce at 8am on a Saturday’ and my oldest saying ‘get baby bruder avaaaay from me’.

Salty Pimp Sundae & Awesomesauce |

Not cool.

So, I did my best and tried to melt as much of the sugar as I could.  In the end, I had to strain what was left of the sugar through and then I added a bit more icing sugar (which is easily dissolved) to make it a bit more sweet.

But do you know what, it was still awesome.  YUM.  YUM. YUM.


My tips:

1. Don’t forget the milk.

2. The chipotle chile is super nice (I got mine from Spice Station).  I didn’t use the cayenne but it would probably make it all that more special.

3. Watch the pot.  Sugar burns, milk boils over.

This really isn’t that hard, so try making it.  It makes a lot so gift it to your neighbour who just returned from an 18 hour plane trip with their two young kids.  Or just eat it yourself.

Salty Pimp Sundae & Awesomesauce |

This goes on top of Big Gay Ice Cream‘s Salty Pimp Sundae which is their best seller.  It comes from their first cookbook which is pretty darn awesome.  It’s awesome because it’s not just about making ice cream (which unfortunately intimidates too many people) but about easy toppings, combos, ways to pimp your ice cream, etc.  It’s fun and original, just like the guys which I was fortunate enough to see when they were in town.

Note that the Salty Pimp uses Not-So-Awesomesauce which is just Awesomesauce without the spices, but I say you can use both.

Use it on your ice cream, as a fruit dip or straight from the pot.

Salty Pimp Ice Cream Sundae
The Salty Pimp is by far and away Big Gay Ice Cream's best selling cone. Try it yourself at home!
  • ¼ cup Dulce de Leche
  • 2 large scoops Vanilla Ice Cream
  • ¼ cup Not-So-Awesomesauce
  • ¼ cup crushed peanuts or cashews
  • coarse sea salt
  • Whipped cream to garnish (Optional)
  1. Squirt (or spoon and swirl) one-quarter of the dulce de leche into the bottom of your ice cream bowl.
  2. Add 1 scoop of ice cream.
  3. Add the half of the remaining dulce de leche and half of the Not-So-Awesomesauce, squirting or drizzling them over the ice cream.
  4. Sprinkle half the nuts and a little sea salt over that.
  5. Add the second scoop of ice cream, then add the remaining dulce de leche, sauce and nuts, repeating the previous step.
  6. Finish with another sprinkle of sea salt and whipped cream, if using, squirting it around the sundae like the tiara on a children's pageant winner.


Awesomesauce and Not-So-Awesomesauce

For the Awesomesauce:
3 cups sugar
1 1/2 cups whole milk
2 cinnamon sticks
6 tablespoons unsalted butter
1/2 cup plus 1 tablespoon unsweetened cocoa powder
1 1/2 teaspoons coarse sea salt
1 teaspoon chipotle chili powder
1/2 teaspoon cayenne pepper
3 ounces semisweet chocolate
1 1/2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract
VARIATION: For Not-So-Awesomesauce (meaning not spicy), leave out the chipotle and cayenne.

For the Not-So-Awesomesauce: Combine the sugar, milk, cinnamon sticks and butter in a large saucepan and whisk vigorously over medium heat for 5-6 minutes, or until completely smooth. There should be no grittiness – all the sugar should be dissolved. Add the cocoa powder, salt, chili powder, cayenne, chocolate and vanilla, and stir until the chocolate is completely melted and incorporated; be sure to scrape the sides and bottom of the saucepan to avoid burning the chocolate. The sauce will be silky and have a nice sheen when ready. Remove the cinnamon sticks. Taste before using and adjust the spices if necessary. Let cool somewhat before spooning over ice cream. Store refrigerated in an airtight container for up to 2 weeks. The leftover Awesomesauce is great reheated, for a sauce, and also good cold as a rich, spicy spread.

Get the Big Gay Ice Cream cookbook for yourself!

Credit to “Salty Pimp Ice Cream Sundae” from BIG GAY ICE CREAM: SAUCY STORIES & FROZEN TREATS: GOING ALL THE WAY WITH ICE CREAM by Bryan Petroff, copyright © 2-15 by Bryan Petroff and Douglas Quint.  Used by permission of Clarkson Potter/Publishers, an imprint of the Crown Publishing Group, a division of Penguin Random House LLC.  All rights reserved.


There are no comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Leave a Comment

Rate this recipe:  

Michelle Little

Writer & Photographer

Originally from the prairies and now in Montreal, I love exploring new places, eating great food and modern design. I'm mom of two wild things and paper and cake make me happy. Photographing your cutie family would make me very happy.

Instagram Photos